eWEEK content material and product suggestions are editorially impartial. We could become profitable whenever you click on on hyperlinks to our companions. Learn More.
A brand new examine finds that synthetic intelligence can create meme captions which are funnier, extra inventive, and extra shareable than these made by people on common. However, with regards to the best possible memes, people nonetheless reign supreme.
Details concerning the meme-creation examine
The analysis, carried out by a world group from Sweden’s KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Germany’s LMU Munich and TU Darmstadt, in contrast meme creation throughout three teams: people working alone, people collaborating with AI, and AI working solely by itself. Using well-liked meme templates, contributors and AI-generated captions have been examined in relatable classes like work, meals, and sports activities.
The examine’s outcomes
Memes created solely by AI, particularly OpenAI’s GPT-4, scored greater on common for humor, creativity, and shareability than these made by people alone or people working with AI. But right here’s the catch: The funniest particular person memes have been nonetheless made by people, whereas human-AI collaborations produced essentially the most inventive and shareable ones.
One key takeaway is that AI-assisted people generated considerably extra meme concepts and located the method simpler; nonetheless, this increase in productiveness didn’t translate to higher-quality memes. As the researchers famous, “The increased productivity of human-AI teams does not lead to better results—just to more results.”
Participants who used AI additionally reported feeling much less possession over their creations, which affected their inventive satisfaction.
The examine highlights a nuanced actuality: While AI can churn out broadly interesting memes because of its coaching on huge quantities of web information, people carry a private contact that sometimes ends in exceptionally humorous content material. The examine is slated to be offered on the 2025 International Conference on Intelligent User Interfaces.
“I regret to announce that the meme Turing Test has been passed,” joked Ethan Mollick, a professor on the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School. Mollick, who research AI, shared the findings on-line, sparking each amusement and concern.
Why are AI memes funnier on common?
The examine means that AI’s capability to determine broadly interesting humor patterns offers it an edge in creating memes that resonate with a large viewers. Human-created memes, however, typically replicate private experiences, which might result in hit-or-miss outcomes.
But not everyone seems to be satisfied. Some critics argue that AI’s success may merely replicate its capability to focus on the “lowest common denominator” of web humor. As Mollick quipped, “Many of you are realizing that most people have terrible taste in memes.”
Study’s limitations and future analysis
The examine isn’t with out its flaws. The meme creation classes have been quick, and contributors didn’t all the time absolutely make the most of the AI instruments. In addition, the crowdsourced evaluators could have biased the outcomes towards mainstream humor, favoring AI-generated memes optimized for broad enchantment.
The researchers recommend future research may discover eventualities the place AI quickly generates a number of concepts, permitting people to curate and refine the most effective content material.
