Samsung has won a major battle in the Apple-Samsung Legal World War. On Tuesday, an appeals court in The Netherlands denied Apple’s request to ban sales in Europe of the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet.
The decision upholds a lower court ruling in August, in which Apple had contended that Samsung illegally copied the iPad’s design. Apple had previously won a Europe-wide preliminary injunction in The Netherlands against Samsung’s Galaxy S, Galaxy S II, and Ace smartphones.
‘No Coincidence’
In December, a U.S. District Court also denied Apple’s motion for a ban on the Tab 10.1, prior to a scheduled trial in July. A temporary ban on the Tab in Australia has expired, and a trial is scheduled in that country in March. Apple also has recently sued Samsung in Germany, seeking a ban on a variety of Samsung products, including the Tab. The German court can consider the Dutch decision in its deliberations.
Tuesday’s decision in Holland said that Apple’s rights to its design were relatively narrow, and that Samsung had not infringed those rights in the design for its tablet. Among other things, the judges pointed out that the iPad and the Tab 10.1 had different backs and sides, and different thicknesses.
In a statement to news media, Samsung said “this ruling again demonstrates that Apple’s products simply do not warrant the intellectual protections it believes.” Apple has not yet commented on the decision.
In an earlier statement, Apple had said that “it’s no coincidence that Samsung’s latest products look a lot like the iPhone and iPad, from the shape of the hardware to the user interface and even the packaging.”
Prior Art
Apple had sought a wider interpretation of its design rights. But the Dutch court found that there were product examples previous to the iPad, or prior art, such as a concept video produced…
Acer Aspire One AO722-0473 11.6-Inch HD Netbook (Espresso Black)Acer AO722-0473 comes with these high level Specs. AMD Dual-Core C-Series Processor C-60 1.0GHz with TurboCORE Technology up to 1….
Coby Kyros 7-Inch Android 2.3 4 GB Internet Touchscreen Tablet – MID7012-4G (Black)Browse the web, watch videos on Youtube, check e-mail, and more on a generous 7 inch LCD screen. Intuitive touchscreen controls po…
